Tuesday, February 26, 2019

A letter to the church I love...

Preface: People who know me well know that for the past six years I have proudly referred to myself as a BaptiMethodist.  Leaving the denomination that raised me (the United Methodist Church) and that I loved so dearly, to follow my call into ministry was a hard one, more painful than most realize.  However, after receiving trusted advice when deciding between Campbell Divinity and Duke Divinity, that I would in deed be able to receive my ordination if I went to Campbell, following God's path for me to Campbell, and then finding out 40 credit hours into my 90 credit hour master's program that the only way I could become ordained was to transfer to a Methodist divinity school with only 10-12 of my 40 hours, I felt I had no choice in order to honor God.  I stayed at Campbell.  My family is in the Methodist Church still, my husband is a United Methodist youth minister, and I am only just now beginning to truly know the world of the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship where I have landed and now call home.  For all of this, I boldly use the phrase BaptiMethodist in discussing my denomination honestly.



Dear United Methodist Church,

Today you have broken my heart.  Not because of decisions made, because in all honesty I was prepared for that outcome, but because of the lack of love, unity, and grace you are showing to the world.  In your name alone, you have taught the world to stand together not divided, you have said we will agree to disagree, and we will ultimately love one another.  The slogan you threw out so strongly when I was a teenager, "Open Hearts, Open Minds, Open Doors," you have now thrown out with the garbage.  I knew very well that this would end ugly, people were too strongly opinionated and too boldly ready to speak hate.  But I had hope still.

I had hope that you would not lash out against one another.  I had hope that you would not try to get in the way of God.  I had hope that you would remember that the world is watching you, representatives of the 3rd largest denomination in the world, to see how we the church would handle conflict such as this.  I had hope that love would flow from the words you spoke.  I had hope that you would stand united and reach across the aisle to extend kindness to those who feel differently than you do.  I had hope that you would show the world Jesus.  I understand having strong beliefs and standing by them.  In fact, I don't wish either side had not stood for what they believe because if it is your conviction, who am I to get in the way of that?  But what I do wish is that grace would have transcended the room in such a way that ears would have been ready to listen to understand rather than to listen to respond.  You, the church, did not act like the church today, and you did not deserve to use the word United in any way you voted.

So what happened? When did we start letting issues divide us so strongly? when did it become ok to respond to someone in such hate instead of love? When did Jesus ever do that?  And brothers and sisters I don't mean one side of the argument or the other, I mean both.  Mark 3:25 says "and if a house is divided against itself, that house will not be able to stand."  This is what you are doing.  It appears as if you hope the house will tumble.  But yet that is NOT who you raised me to be. Unfortunately, the church that helped me become the follower of Christ that I am today died long before a vote ever happened today.

The church that raised me lived out that "Open" motto in everything it taught.  It welcomed teenagers into spaces knowing every single one had baggage and differences and sins and said you are loved.  It welcomed us into Annual Conference Session for youth and taught us to be respectful with our amendments and comments and questions and votes.  It said come gather with people from around the world and lets talk about how to end hatred and violence and war and injustice.  It asked each of us to always consider if we were living like Jesus.  And it did all of these things while always showing grace.  Even in the midst of an event where grace was not shown, you as the church apologized to us as youth to try to show us this wasn't ok and we had to do better.  You, the church did this and taught this and set this example.

Again, so what happened?  You do realize young people are leaving the church at the startling rate of 3500 people every day?  They want authenticity.  They want to know they aren't "too bad for God." They want you to show them what love and grace looks like.  They will not stand for how you treated one another today. I can only hope there were not too many people that were undecided about church watching today because if they were, you closed the doors of the church, any denomination, for them permanently today.  For those who have been told today you are unwelcome, I can only say I'm sorry.  You don't need to hear where else you are welcome today because you just lost your home.  That would be like telling a parent who just lost your child that its ok because they have another one.  I just want you to know that you are still worthy of the love of God and you still should be treated with kindness, love, and grace.  No matter how anyone feels about your life choices.

Today I don't denounce my BaptiMethodism because today I am more sure of it than ever before.  But today I mourn the loss of the United Methodist Church because never again can you honestly claim that title.

God may you continue to work in and through your people.  Allow us to hear you speak.  Help us to act on your behalf.  And help us to trust that you are not through with this yet. We pray in the only words now possible.

In Christ's servanthood,
a BaptiMethodist